The art of tendering: Negotiation versus technology

Freight Tenders or freight RFQ’s are an integral part of shipping and logistics for the carriers, shippers and freight forwarders. With complexity on the uprise, what is really making a difference in a logistics tenders…negotiation skills or technology?

Negotiation versus technology

The inspiration for this article The Art of Tendering: Negotiations versus technology, came from a recent blog and research by American Shipper on Logistics Procurement. First, let’s take a closer look at the blog.

1. The art of handling a freight tender – By Hariesh Manaadiar ( Shipping and Freight Resource)

This informing blog, written earlier this year by Hariesh Manaadiar, is a spot-on description of what is going on, in general, in freight tendering today. The workload and data related to freight procurement are now beyond a human scale problem.  The complexity of transport tenders nowadays surely motivated Hariesh to write the article:

‘Because the majority of the tenders are quite complicated and capable of pushing people over the edge due to its complexity with its tight deadlines and the nearly impossible task of compacting the costs.’

People in our industry who have handled some complicated global freight tender will surely understand what Hariesh describes. To underline the level of complexity, Hariesh comes up with a great example of a Multinational shipper, but this could easily be projected to the internal situation of many freight forwarders in the industry with a little imagination.

‘Imagine a MNC (Multi-National Company) who have multiple brands to be exported from their 20 odd group companies to around 200 countries globally where they are present. Imagine the logistics division of the above multinational. In each of these countries trying to secure the best rate for shipping their products from A to B which may translate into thousands of containers over a short period of time. Or imagine you are one of the lucky service providers invited to bid or tender for this business. Visualize the dynamics involved in coordinating the movement of these containers across the 20 operating companies into 200 countries for these thousands of containers.’

It’s complex, it’s immense and mind-blowing altogether. No matter what side of the tender you are at. Secondly, but shortly after, I found a very interesting report investigating the adoption of technology in logistics procurement. Knowing the numbers and facts of last year, I was keen to have a closer look at this.


2. Research: Technolgy in Freight Procurement


According to this year’s American Shipper Transportation Procurement Benchmark Study, half of the companies still rely on manual processes to address this critical function. Nevertheless, freight procurement has seen a period of rapid change recently, with the onus on shippers and logistics services providers to invest in technology and become adept at collecting, managing and using data to improve their procurement function.

There seems to be a clear relation between technology, negotiation skills and the success rate of a freight tender. So why are half of the companies still making use of manual approaches? Why does more than 70% of shippers interviewed feel their procurement tech is average at best?

Very surprising figures if you ask me. Especially, if you take a good look at the key dynamics impacting freight procurement. All of which can be addressed with the right, modern technology.


1. Increasing contract and spot rate transparency

2. The transportation procurement team is not well coordinated with sourcing and merchandising teams

3. Tight supply on my specific lanes

4. Lack of technology

5. Changing trade regulations causing a company to source in new locations


Anno 2017, it is undeniable that technology is becoming increasingly important in logistics. This is backed by the number of tech start-ups in the industry, but also by the strong data-driven demand that industry leaders have put into operation over the last 3 years. Yet, only 50% of the companies worldwide are relying (partially) on Transportation Procurement Technology. While managing the data related to freight procurement is now beyond a human scale problem. But what about the manual aspect of tenders, the negotiating?



Perhaps the biggest barrier currently in logistics procurement is the knowledge people have on the available solutions. Or the perception of the capabilities of E-procurement tools. Off course, negotiation skills remain a vital part of the business. Moreover, procurement is nowadays all about building strategic relationships rather than squeezing an extra buck out of your supplier. And that is specifically where modern technology can play its part. Procurement must ensure that:

  1. Suppliers do not feel commoditized (picked from a large, general database)
  2. Suppliers are closely involved with the project
  3. Suppliers must be able to work with your E-procurement tools (easy, fast, support available)

1st generation freight procurement tools brought it online, 2nd generation tools provided all functionalities as we know them today, but the 3rd generation really made procurement intuitive and easy, both for the tender party as the suppliers.

In my opinion, the effective Freight Tender manager is not some smart Excel jockey or an ultimate scenario builder. He or she is a logistics-driven professional that keeps numbers in balance with reality and has great empathy towards carriers which results in effective communication and negotiation with carriers. Bottom line, in order to be successful, you will both need negotiation skills and solid technology at your fingertips!


About Freightender – Freight Sourcing content


Freightender is the latest solution in the Logistics Procurement sector. A strong combination of deep logistics knowledge and the latest IT-technologies makes our freight sourcing platform the most time and cost-effective solution available in the market today.

We offer a complete, cloud-based solution that allows you to easily create and manage transport tenders while ensuring deep scenario building and comprehensive simulations. Furthermore, the tool saves procurement an enormous amount of time as it automates all Excel number crunching, reporting, and analysis. For more information, please find enclosed our brochure. 

More Freightender E-Tendering content


  1. Freight Forwarders: 5 Habits That Will Improve Tender Management
  2. LTL Transportation: 7 Quick Tips To Save Money

  3. 10 Things That Make Your Procurement Process Terrible And Less Effective

Pieter Kinds

Pieter Kinds


Freightender is the standard in freight tendering. It makes the tender process lean, smarter and much faster. 
Fully cloud-based. Curious? Request a free live demo and join the Freight Tender Revolution!

Schedule Demo Freight Sourcing

Schedule Demo RFQ Management

E-Sourcing freight checklist: What is logistics looking for?

Despite the fact that the procurement and transportation sectors are slow adopters of technology, the rat race has already begun. Many companies are inquiring the platform provides full visibility all the different steps in the project and the timing associated....

Spot bidding: what to expect in Q3-Q4 2020?

Decisions made in logistics and supply chain always have had a strong impact on a company's bottom line. It was, is and always will be a major factor to accomplish competitive advantage in any industry. One of the decisions enterprises confront is the question of...

State of logistics procurement in EMEA
(and where the market is headed)

We want to give you a short overview of what is happening in the world of logistics procurement from our perspective. LTL/FTL Freight The market has dropped enormously for most carriers. Estimates go from 50 to 80% of the business. Most shippers are holding off on new...

Why forwarders and carriers are pricing transportation into oblivion

Carriers are pricing transportation into oblivion Pricing, quoting, answering to transport tenders, whatever you call the process, is a highly underrated process within many forwarder and carrier organizations. It is a process that is subject to shared...

5 simple freight tender tips for 2020

5 simple freight tender tips for 2020 The logistics market is ever evolving and has never been more dynamic than in 2020. Globalization, digitization and political events such as Brexit make that logistics professionals need to be on their toes to ensure ongoing...

How do you rally your carriers around your freight tender?

How do you rally your carriers around your freight tender? For many, shippers and carriers alike, freight tenders are a necessary evil, yet one has to put in full effort to get satisfying results. Often this does not happen and tenders are not complete, are stretched...

Freight Fowarders: Make tenders easy together with Freightender

Are you ready for groundbreaking new technology to manage internal freight tenders? A brand-new solution from Freightender for all the parties involved within a carrier organization. This Internal Tender Management Solution is designed for forwarders and 3PL's....

Procurement of freight – emerging trends that will hit us by 2020

Are you overpaying for the procurement of Freight and RFP projects because you have been made to believe that logistics sourcing should take a lot of consultants resources and difficult calculations?    Are you paying a fortune to do excel calculations and...

3 Useful Tips From Experts In LTL Tenders

Tendering your Less-Than-Truckload (LTL) freight is often a sensitive exercise for companies. First, it is time-consuming. But moreover, the results of the tender strongly depend on a solid baseline setup.  In addition to that, a good understanding of the current...

Freight tender process: Modern solutions versus legacy tools

What is the difference between old and new technology in logistics sourcing and procurement? How does it affect the freight tender process? The time of tendering freight and logistics services via outdated, generic platforms is slowly coming to an end. Carrier users...